suikoden two cant find suikoden 1 data

[tichyfurball]

For whatever reason, the memcard got de-formatted, and when I reformatted it, I lost my data for both suikoden games. I decided to download a save file from gamefaqs of suikoden 1, so i didn't have to replay all of it again. i downloaded the file, converted it to a .mcr, and put it in the memcard folder. then i configured the memcard to put the 2nd memcard as the suikoden 1 save. yet when i try to load the suikoden 1 data off of memory card 2, it says theres no suikoden 1 data! please help.